How did the editor respond to our suggestion

Author: mjhv

August undefined, 2024

Web11 de set. de 2024 · A Sample Response to the Comments of Peer Reviewers. Edward Researcher. Palaeography Institute. 1717 Writer’s Lane. South River, MI, USA, 484848. 734-734-7344. [email protected]. Dr Helen … Web2. Prepare a document of response. Think about every comment and how you wish to respond. When writing your responses, be clear, concise and use evidence to show your changes or reasons why you have dealt with the comments in a particular way. 3. Respond to every comment and suggested change, one by one.

Twelve Tips for Editors, and One Suggestion – Association …

Web23 de abr. de 2024 · In “To the Reader,” Thomas Feyer, the Letters editor since 1999, explains what qualifies as a publishable letter to the editor. As you read, highlight or underline Mr. Feyer’s suggestions. Web16 de out. de 2015 · Tips for Writing Responses to Reviewers. 1. Do not use an aggressive or defensive tone. 2. Never use one reviewer’s response against another. 3. Thank reviewers for good suggestions. 4. Say ... date night ideas in phoenix arizona

Response to Reviewers [Cover Letter] - Copernicus.org

Webpraised. Errors were ignored, and no suggestions for im-provement were made. No grade was marked on any paper. One week from the time the first papers were written, they were returned to the students. Students were asked to reread their papers, noting any comment that had been written on them. They were asked to consider how they might WebWe are grateful to the reviewer#2 for your appreciation of the value of our work. We thank you very much for providing many detailed suggestions and comments, most of which are excellent suggestions and we adopted. Please find specific comments below. Page 24919, line 9: The authors mention the vertical levels of 5 km and 9 km. Web12 de out. de 2024 · The response letter will typically begin with a summary of changes, pointing out new data and new analyses performed in response to the most essential criticisms of all the reviewers. Note that, at your discretion, the response may include figures and tables that are for the reviewers' benefit but will not go into the manuscript or … date night ideas in pittsburgh pa

How should I respond if I cannot address a reviewer

Expressions to make and respond suggestions - Juicy English

Web21 de nov. de 2024 · So the answer is yes, editors sometimes rewrite. Their job is to help the book come out in all its potential and to serve well the publishing line of the house. Web8 de ago. de 2016 · Here are responses to the reviewer comments: Comment 1: Language editing for the manuscript has been done. I have used the services of a professional editing company for the same. Editorial Formatting comments: All the suggestions regarding editorial formatting have been incorporated. Comment 2: Use a 1" margin on all sides: Done date night ideas in orange countyWebResponse to Editor Dear editor, We thank you very much for the comments and suggestions. The comments and suggestions are valuable and very helpful for revising … bixby smartwatch

"Web11 de nov. de 2024 · Unfortunately, the authors failed to update the reference list, and failed to respond to these comments. There are no changes on the manuscript. Authors should address any comments given by reviewers, in a point-to-point response; even if they do not want to consider the comments or suggestions from reviewers they must address their … " - How did the editor respond to our suggestion

How did the editor respond to our suggestion

Sample Response to Reviewers - American Psychological Association

Web12 de fev. de 2015 · According to Dr. van Harten, the simplest way to ensure your responses are informative is to "copy paste each reviewer comment, and type your … Web20 de out. de 2024 · 1. Read the letter from the editor Read the letter from the editor carefully and make sure that you have indeed received a request to revise and resubmit …

Did you know?

Web18 de mai. de 2016 · Answer: I think you should just be honest and mention to the editor that while you agree with the reviewer’s suggestion, you had not thought of this at the … WebDear editor, We very much appreciated your encouraging and insightful comments and those of the referees. We have endeavoured to respond to all suggestions and comments, which further improved the understanding and potential impact of our manuscript. Detailed responses are given below (in blue).

WebDear Editor, We appreciate you and the reviewers for your precious time in reviewing our paper and providing valuable comments. It was your valuable and insightful comments that led to possible improvements in the current version. The authors have carefully considered the comments and tried our best to address every one of them. Web16 de out. de 2015 · Tips for Writing Responses to Reviewers 1. Do not use an aggressive or defensive tone. 2. Never use one reviewer’s response against another. 3. Thank …

Web7 de mai. de 2024 · The purpose of this editorial is to offer suggestions to authors about some effective ways to respond to reviewers’ and editors’ comments, leading to manuscript revision and subsequent better chances for possible acceptance by the Journal. 1. Understand the importance of the peer review process. Web10 de mai. de 2024 · The etiquette of suggestions: Good manners and wisdom prevent you from saying, “That’s stupid.”. #1. Suggestions impose social obligations. You need to consider and respond. #2. People believe their stupid suggestions are smart. We believe our suggestions are helpful. That’s why we offered them.

Webappreciate the time and effort that you and the reviewers dedicated to providing feedback on our manuscript and are grateful for the insightful comments on and valuable …

date night ideas in rochester mnWebIt is not a guideline on ‘how to write a journal paper’ but useful comments and suggestions are provided. The final part of this chapter covers questions related to the submission and revision ... bixby sloughWeb1 de jan. de 2008 · Reviewing and editing is not a democratic process, with everyone having one vote. The editor is The Decider (borrowing from George Bush). The reviews provide … bixby smart displayWeb7 de mai. de 2024 · It is up to you. The editors clearly think you should have a chance to respond to the reviewers, then they will evaluate if your paper is wowrthwhile for publication. The review is not a democratic process, the editor may at any point overrule the suggestion of the reviewers. The editor may even have an idea about the topic you are … date night ideas in sacramentoWebTake a day (or at least a couple of hours), and fully embrace the editor's suggestions. Think about why h/she made them, and think about how you would revise your paper to fully incorporate his/her suggestions, and in what aspects it would make the paper better. … date night ideas in portland maineWeb17 de jan. de 2024 · The handling Editor, based on all the information available, including referee reports, can nominate the paper for its particular interest, as well as clarity of … bixby snyder thats not my problemWeb22 de mar. de 2013 · The responsibility to accept the paper as such is not yours, it's the editor's. You simply mention that you believe something is wrong with the current paper, you explain why you believe it's wrong, and whether you think it … bixby soccer club